Curious comment from William Leith:
When I started reading children’s books to my son, I began to notice something. All the male characters seemed to be idiots. The Gruffalo was an idiot. Duffy Driver was an idiot. Tiddler was an idiot. The male characters seemed to be careless, stupid, greedy or selfish – the fish that gets lost, the dad who won’t tidy the house, the dad who doesn’t listen. On the other hand, the female characters were resourceful and smart.
I’ve been reading children’s books to my son for nearly three years, and I can’t say I’ve ever noticed this. Leith is being a bit unfair, I think. Let’s start with the Gruffalo. The Gruffalo may indeed be an idiot – he falls for the mouse’s deception much too easily – but is he really recognisably male? Although he is referred to throughout as ‘he’, there is nothing particularly male about him. ‘He’ is just a deeply strange creature of indeterminate gender.
As for Duffy Driver, I don’t think he’s an idiot; he gets into scrapes sometimes, but he is also resourceful and considerate to his passengers. It might have been a bit stupid of him to drive the Little Red Train through several European countries without noticing, but doesn’t he deserve some credit simply for achieving it? It’s kind of impressive when you think about it – and his only crime was to follow the signals correctly.
Tiddler, meanwhile, is far from being an idiot – he is just a cheeky, highly inventive storyteller. It might be a bit naughty of him always to be late for school, but his wild and wacky explanations make up for it by keeping everyone entertained. Yes, he did get lost, but who wouldn’t get lost every now and then if they lived in an ocean?
Besides, I am sure there are plenty of examples of female characters in kids’ books being idiots too – just need to think of some. Hmmm. How about Goldilocks, for starters? And Lily, who is always losing the Blue Kangaroo? The Gruffalo’s Child is so dumb that she thinks the mouse’s shadow is a scary monster, while Mog, clearly identified as a female cat, is described by her creator as ‘not very clever’. Any more?